How to Prove Adultery in South Carolina Divorce Cases: Evidence Requirements and Legal Standards

• View Larger Image

How to Prove Adultery in South Carolina Divorce Cases: Evidence Requirements and Legal Standards

How to Prove Adultery in South Carolina Divorce Cases: Evidence Requirements and Legal Standards
Understanding Adultery as Grounds for Divorce in South Carolina
Adultery remains one of the five fault-based grounds for divorce in South Carolina, carrying significant implications for alimony, property division, and sometimes custody determinations. Under South Carolina Code § 20-3-10, adultery is defined as voluntary sexual intercourse between a married person and someone other than their spouse. However, proving adultery in South Carolina requires meeting specific evidentiary standards that can challenge even experienced family law practitioners.

The Legal Standard: Clear and Convincing Evidence
South Carolina courts require “clear and convincing evidence” to prove adultery – a standard higher than the typical preponderance of evidence but lower than beyond reasonable doubt. This means the evidence must be substantially more likely true than not true, creating a firm belief in the fact finder’s mind that adultery occurred.

The South Carolina Supreme Court has consistently held that adultery can be proven through circumstantial evidence showing both inclination and opportunity. Direct evidence, such as catching the spouse in the act, is not required and rarely available in practice.

Essential Elements: Inclination and Opportunity
Proving Inclination
Inclination refers to the adulterous disposition between the parties – evidence showing mutual romantic or sexual attraction. South Carolina courts have accepted various forms of evidence to establish inclination:

Public displays of affection beyond casual friendship
Romantic correspondence, including text messages, emails, and social media interactions
Testimony regarding intimate behavior in public settings
Evidence of gift-giving or financial support typical of romantic relationships
Witness testimony about the nature of the observed relationship

Establishing Opportunity
Opportunity means proving the suspected parties had the chance to commit adultery. South Carolina courts look for evidence showing the parties were together under circumstances where adultery could have occurred:

Overnight stays at hotels, residences, or other private locations
Extended periods alone together in vehicles or secluded areas
Regular meetings at times and places conducive to intimate relations
Travel together, especially overnight trips
Cohabitation or frequent visits to one party’s residence

Types of Evidence Used in South Carolina Adultery Cases
Documentary Evidence
Text Messages and Electronic Communications: South Carolina courts regularly admit text messages, emails, and social media messages as evidence of adultery. These communications often provide the strongest evidence of inclination, particularly when they contain explicit content, discussions of meetings, or expressions of romantic feelings.
Financial Records: Credit card statements, bank records, and receipts can establish patterns of behavior supporting adultery claims. Hotels charges, restaurant bills for two, jewelry purchases, and unexplained cash withdrawals all serve as circumstantial evidence.
Phone Records: Call logs and frequency of communication can demonstrate the extent of a relationship, especially when combined with testimony about the spouse’s secretive behavior regarding their phone.
Digital Evidence
Social Media Activity: Facebook, Instagram, and other social media platforms often contain valuable evidence. Photos together, check-ins at the same locations, and public interactions can establish both inclination and opportunity.
Dating App Profiles: Discovery of active profiles on dating applications while married provides strong evidence of inclination to commit adultery, even without proof of actual meetings.
GPS and Location Data: Vehicle GPS systems, smartphone location history, and fitness tracker data can place parties together at specific times and locations.

Witness Testimony
Private Investigator Reports: Many South Carolina divorce attorneys recommend hiring licensed private investigators to gather admissible evidence. Investigators can provide surveillance footage, photographs, and detailed reports of observed behavior.
Third-Party Witnesses: Friends, family members, coworkers, or neighbors who observed the relationship can provide crucial testimony. South Carolina courts give particular weight to disinterested witnesses with no stake in the divorce outcome.
Paramour Testimony: While rare, the alleged paramour can be subpoenaed to testify. They may invoke Fifth Amendment protections against self-incrimination, as adultery remains a misdemeanor in South Carolina under § 16-15-60, though rarely prosecuted.

Legal Procedures for Proving Adultery in South Carolina
Discovery Process
South Carolina Family Court Rules provide extensive discovery tools for gathering evidence of adultery:

Interrogatories: Written questions requiring sworn answers about relationships, whereabouts, and conduct. Rule 33, SCRCP, permits up to 50 interrogatories in family court proceedings.
Requests for Production: Demands for documents, electronic records, and tangible evidence. Parties must preserve and produce relevant evidence or face spoliation sanctions.
Depositions: Sworn testimony taken outside court, allowing detailed questioning of the spouse, paramour, and witnesses under oath.
Requests for Admission: Strategic tool requiring parties to admit or deny specific facts about their conduct and relationships.

Temporary Hearings
Evidence of adultery can be presented at temporary hearings under South Carolina Family Court Rule 21. While the court makes no final determinations at this stage, evidence of adultery may influence temporary support orders and custody arrangements.

Trial Presentation
At trial, adultery evidence must be presented methodically to establish both elements. South Carolina judges expect:

Chronological presentation showing relationship development
Clear connection between evidence and the inclination/opportunity test
Authentication of all documentary and electronic evidence
Witness credibility assessments
Rebuttal of any innocent explanations offered by the defending spouse

Defenses Against Adultery Allegations
Condonation
Under South Carolina law, condonation occurs when the innocent spouse forgives the adultery and resumes marital relations. Continued cohabitation after knowledge of adultery may constitute condonation, barring its use as divorce grounds.

Recrimination
If both spouses committed adultery, South Carolina’s recrimination doctrine historically barred either from obtaining a divorce on that ground. However, modern courts may still grant divorce while considering mutual fault in property and alimony determinations.

Insufficient Evidence
The most common defense challenges whether the evidence meets the clear and convincing standard. Innocent explanations for suspicious behavior, lack of corroboration, and credibility attacks on witnesses can defeat adultery claims.

Impact of Proven Adultery on Divorce Outcomes
Alimony Considerations
South Carolina Code § 20-3-130(A) explicitly bars alimony awards to spouses who commit adultery, unless specific circumstances apply. The statute provides narrow exceptions, making adultery proof particularly significant in alimony disputes.

Property Division
While South Carolina follows equitable distribution principles, proven adultery constitutes marital fault affecting property division under § 20-3-620(B)(2). Courts may award a greater share to the innocent spouse, though not as automatic punishment.

Custody Determinations
Adultery alone rarely determines custody, as South Carolina courts focus on the best interests of children. However, adultery may impact custody if it:

Exposed children to inappropriate situations
Demonstrated poor judgment affecting parenting ability
Occurred in circumstances endangering children’s welfare

Strategic Considerations for South Carolina Attorneys
Timing of Adultery Allegations
Raising adultery claims early through pleadings triggers heightened emotion and potential retaliation. Consider whether strategic advantage exists in withholding allegations until discovery confirms sufficient evidence.

Cost-Benefit Analysis
Proving adultery requires substantial resources – private investigators, forensic technology experts, and extensive discovery. Weigh potential benefits against costs, particularly when other grounds exist or fault won’t significantly impact outcomes.

Ethical Boundaries
South Carolina Rule of Professional Conduct 4.4 prohibits methods that serve merely to embarrass or burden third parties. Avoid overreaching in pursuit of adultery evidence, particularly regarding the paramour’s privacy rights.

Settlement Leverage
Strong adultery evidence often motivates settlement to avoid public trial testimony. Use evidence strategically in negotiations while maintaining professional ethics and client objectives.

South Carolina Decisions on Adultery
The South Carolina Court of Appeals continues refining adultery proof standards. Recent decisions emphasize:

Electronic evidence authentication requirements
Privacy limitations on obtaining digital evidence
Circumstantial evidence sufficiency standards
Condonation analysis in modern relationships

Practitioners should monitor appellate decisions for evolving standards and strategic insights.
Practical Tips for Clients Suspecting Adultery
Document Preservation
Advise clients to immediately preserve potential evidence:

Screenshot suspicious messages before deletion
Document unusual schedules and absences
Maintain records of marital fund expenditures
Secure access to joint financial accounts

Avoiding Illegal Evidence Gathering
Counsel clients against:

Hacking spouse’s accounts or devices
Illegal recording without consent
Trespassing or stalking behavior
Destroying spouse’s property or evidence

Professional Investigation
Recommend licensed private investigators familiar with South Carolina evidence rules. Professional investigation avoids legal pitfalls while gathering admissible evidence.

Conclusion
Proving adultery in South Carolina divorces requires careful evidence gathering, strategic presentation, and thorough understanding of legal standards. While challenging, successful adultery claims significantly impact divorce outcomes, particularly regarding alimony eligibility. Attorneys must balance aggressive advocacy with ethical obligations, focusing on admissible evidence that satisfies the inclination and opportunity test under clear and convincing standards.

As South Carolina family law continues evolving, particularly regarding digital evidence and privacy rights, maintaining current knowledge of statutory requirements and case law developments remains essential for effective representation in adultery-based divorce proceedings.

This article provides general information about South Carolina family law and should not be construed as legal advice. Each case presents unique circumstances requiring consultation with qualified South Carolina family law attorneys. For specific guidance on proving adultery in your divorce case, contact an experienced family law practitioner familiar with your local court procedures.

By Suzanne Klok|2025-11-12T16:06:45+00:00July 15th, 2023|Adultery, Divorce|Comments Off on How to Prove Adultery in South Carolina Divorce Cases: Evidence Requirements and Legal Standards

Share This Story, Choose Your Platform!

About the Author: Suzanne Klok

Related Posts

South Carolina Rule 21 Updates 2025: Temporary Hearings

Filing for Divorce While Living Together in South Carolina: Watson v. Watson

New Changes to South Carolina Split Custody Agreements

An Introduction to South Carolina’s Military Divorce Laws

The One-Year Requirement in Filing for a No-Fault Divorce

How to Prove Adultery in South Carolina Divorce Cases: Evidence Requirements and Legal Standards
Understanding Adultery as Grounds for Divorce in South Carolina
Adultery remains one of the five fault-based grounds for divorce in South Carolina, carrying significant implications for alimony, property division, and sometimes custody determinations. Under South Carolina Code § 20-3-10, adultery is defined as voluntary sexual intercourse between a married person and someone other than their spouse. However, proving adultery in South Carolina requires meeting specific evidentiary standards that can challenge even experienced family law practitioners.

The Legal Standard: Clear and Convincing Evidence
South Carolina courts require “clear and convincing evidence” to prove adultery – a standard higher than the typical preponderance of evidence but lower than beyond reasonable doubt. This means the evidence must be substantially more likely true than not true, creating a firm belief in the fact finder’s mind that adultery occurred.

The South Carolina Supreme Court has consistently held that adultery can be proven through circumstantial evidence showing both inclination and opportunity. Direct evidence, such as catching the spouse in the act, is not required and rarely available in practice.

Essential Elements: Inclination and Opportunity
Proving Inclination
Inclination refers to the adulterous disposition between the parties – evidence showing mutual romantic or sexual attraction. South Carolina courts have accepted various forms of evidence to establish inclination:

Public displays of affection beyond casual friendship
Romantic correspondence, including text messages, emails, and social media interactions
Testimony regarding intimate behavior in public settings
Evidence of gift-giving or financial support typical of romantic relationships
Witness testimony about the nature of the observed relationship

Establishing Opportunity
Opportunity means proving the suspected parties had the chance to commit adultery. South Carolina courts look for evidence showing the parties were together under circumstances where adultery could have occurred:

Overnight stays at hotels, residences, or other private locations
Extended periods alone together in vehicles or secluded areas
Regular meetings at times and places conducive to intimate relations
Travel together, especially overnight trips
Cohabitation or frequent visits to one party’s residence

Types of Evidence Used in South Carolina Adultery Cases
Documentary Evidence
Text Messages and Electronic Communications: South Carolina courts regularly admit text messages, emails, and social media messages as evidence of adultery. These communications often provide the strongest evidence of inclination, particularly when they contain explicit content, discussions of meetings, or expressions of romantic feelings.
Financial Records: Credit card statements, bank records, and receipts can establish patterns of behavior supporting adultery claims. Hotels charges, restaurant bills for two, jewelry purchases, and unexplained cash withdrawals all serve as circumstantial evidence.
Phone Records: Call logs and frequency of communication can demonstrate the extent of a relationship, especially when combined with testimony about the spouse’s secretive behavior regarding their phone.
Digital Evidence
Social Media Activity: Facebook, Instagram, and other social media platforms often contain valuable evidence. Photos together, check-ins at the same locations, and public interactions can establish both inclination and opportunity.
Dating App Profiles: Discovery of active profiles on dating applications while married provides strong evidence of inclination to commit adultery, even without proof of actual meetings.
GPS and Location Data: Vehicle GPS systems, smartphone location history, and fitness tracker data can place parties together at specific times and locations.

Witness Testimony
Private Investigator Reports: Many South Carolina divorce attorneys recommend hiring licensed private investigators to gather admissible evidence. Investigators can provide surveillance footage, photographs, and detailed reports of observed behavior.
Third-Party Witnesses: Friends, family members, coworkers, or neighbors who observed the relationship can provide crucial testimony. South Carolina courts give particular weight to disinterested witnesses with no stake in the divorce outcome.
Paramour Testimony: While rare, the alleged paramour can be subpoenaed to testify. They may invoke Fifth Amendment protections against self-incrimination, as adultery remains a misdemeanor in South Carolina under § 16-15-60, though rarely prosecuted.

Legal Procedures for Proving Adultery in South Carolina
Discovery Process
South Carolina Family Court Rules provide extensive discovery tools for gathering evidence of adultery:

Interrogatories: Written questions requiring sworn answers about relationships, whereabouts, and conduct. Rule 33, SCRCP, permits up to 50 interrogatories in family court proceedings.
Requests for Production: Demands for documents, electronic records, and tangible evidence. Parties must preserve and produce relevant evidence or face spoliation sanctions.
Depositions: Sworn testimony taken outside court, allowing detailed questioning of the spouse, paramour, and witnesses under oath.
Requests for Admission: Strategic tool requiring parties to admit or deny specific facts about their conduct and relationships.

Temporary Hearings
Evidence of adultery can be presented at temporary hearings under South Carolina Family Court Rule 21. While the court makes no final determinations at this stage, evidence of adultery may influence temporary support orders and custody arrangements.

Trial Presentation
At trial, adultery evidence must be presented methodically to establish both elements. South Carolina judges expect:

Chronological presentation showing relationship development
Clear connection between evidence and the inclination/opportunity test
Authentication of all documentary and electronic evidence
Witness credibility assessments
Rebuttal of any innocent explanations offered by the defending spouse

Defenses Against Adultery Allegations
Condonation
Under South Carolina law, condonation occurs when the innocent spouse forgives the adultery and resumes marital relations. Continued cohabitation after knowledge of adultery may constitute condonation, barring its use as divorce grounds.

Recrimination
If both spouses committed adultery, South Carolina’s recrimination doctrine historically barred either from obtaining a divorce on that ground. However, modern courts may still grant divorce while considering mutual fault in property and alimony determinations.

Insufficient Evidence
The most common defense challenges whether the evidence meets the clear and convincing standard. Innocent explanations for suspicious behavior, lack of corroboration, and credibility attacks on witnesses can defeat adultery claims.

Impact of Proven Adultery on Divorce Outcomes
Alimony Considerations
South Carolina Code § 20-3-130(A) explicitly bars alimony awards to spouses who commit adultery, unless specific circumstances apply. The statute provides narrow exceptions, making adultery proof particularly significant in alimony disputes.

Property Division
While South Carolina follows equitable distribution principles, proven adultery constitutes marital fault affecting property division under § 20-3-620(B)(2). Courts may award a greater share to the innocent spouse, though not as automatic punishment.

Custody Determinations
Adultery alone rarely determines custody, as South Carolina courts focus on the best interests of children. However, adultery may impact custody if it:

Exposed children to inappropriate situations
Demonstrated poor judgment affecting parenting ability
Occurred in circumstances endangering children’s welfare

Strategic Considerations for South Carolina Attorneys
Timing of Adultery Allegations
Raising adultery claims early through pleadings triggers heightened emotion and potential retaliation. Consider whether strategic advantage exists in withholding allegations until discovery confirms sufficient evidence.

Cost-Benefit Analysis
Proving adultery requires substantial resources – private investigators, forensic technology experts, and extensive discovery. Weigh potential benefits against costs, particularly when other grounds exist or fault won’t significantly impact outcomes.

Ethical Boundaries
South Carolina Rule of Professional Conduct 4.4 prohibits methods that serve merely to embarrass or burden third parties. Avoid overreaching in pursuit of adultery evidence, particularly regarding the paramour’s privacy rights.

Settlement Leverage
Strong adultery evidence often motivates settlement to avoid public trial testimony. Use evidence strategically in negotiations while maintaining professional ethics and client objectives.

South Carolina Decisions on Adultery
The South Carolina Court of Appeals continues refining adultery proof standards. Recent decisions emphasize:

Electronic evidence authentication requirements
Privacy limitations on obtaining digital evidence
Circumstantial evidence sufficiency standards
Condonation analysis in modern relationships

Practitioners should monitor appellate decisions for evolving standards and strategic insights.
Practical Tips for Clients Suspecting Adultery
Document Preservation
Advise clients to immediately preserve potential evidence:

Screenshot suspicious messages before deletion
Document unusual schedules and absences
Maintain records of marital fund expenditures
Secure access to joint financial accounts

Avoiding Illegal Evidence Gathering
Counsel clients against:

Hacking spouse’s accounts or devices
Illegal recording without consent
Trespassing or stalking behavior
Destroying spouse’s property or evidence

Professional Investigation
Recommend licensed private investigators familiar with South Carolina evidence rules. Professional investigation avoids legal pitfalls while gathering admissible evidence.

Conclusion
Proving adultery in South Carolina divorces requires careful evidence gathering, strategic presentation, and thorough understanding of legal standards. While challenging, successful adultery claims significantly impact divorce outcomes, particularly regarding alimony eligibility. Attorneys must balance aggressive advocacy with ethical obligations, focusing on admissible evidence that satisfies the inclination and opportunity test under clear and convincing standards.

As South Carolina family law continues evolving, particularly regarding digital evidence and privacy rights, maintaining current knowledge of statutory requirements and case law developments remains essential for effective representation in adultery-based divorce proceedings.

This article provides general information about South Carolina family law and should not be construed as legal advice. Each case presents unique circumstances requiring consultation with qualified South Carolina family law attorneys. For specific guidance on proving adultery in your divorce case, contact an experienced family law practitioner familiar with your local court procedures.